5 Comments
User's avatar
BrianM's avatar

I think there's another factor that people have been underplaying, the economy. The West in general and the US in particular are just starting to feel the impacts that have been felt in Asia for weeks. While the US is more self sufficient in the resources that come out of the Gulf, it is not entirely so. But more importantly, those resource markets and industrial chains tend to be global in nature. Price rises and shortages property though the entire system. The US cannot insulate itself completely from the global economy. As this drags on, the economic blowback will continue to build. Eventually, it will no longer be possible for Trump to manipulate the markets with happy talking points and reality will hit. Oil will go way up and the stock market will go way down. That could happen at any time and will hit Trump in a way he cares about, possibly forcing a change in approach. We'll see.

the suck of sorrow's avatar

One thing Wilkerson and Johnson have in common is a grave concern over the US national debt. But the US is not a kitchen table. The debt is denominated in dollars which only we can create.

Modern Monetary Theory (MMT) shows that every debt has a surplus so the biggest hazard would be inflation due to a lack of resources. MMT proponents see the US and its large population as being resource rich.

But are we truly resource rich? I don't think we are if the goal is to replenish our military weapons. There is a severe shortage of rare earths to create the electronic controls for all manner of weapon systems. Too, we lack the industrial skills to restart manufacturing facilities for all weapon system components. Large numbers of machinists and the machine tools for them to operate are now missing.

Take helium. What's more important: the MRI for a medical diagnosis or the etching for a chip that directs the homing of a missile onto a hospital ward?

Among a host of shortages, stainless steel is going to be extremely difficult to manufacture.

My take is that we can develop defensive capability, but not offensive capability. To develop offensive systems takes us outside the bounds of MMT as we do not have the resources.

Iran and the Houthis have demonstrated that our glory (a rather perverse sense of the word) days are past.

I fear we as a nation cannot deal with defeat. (We elide true analysis of previous military escapades.) I hope that directing our thoughts towards responsible stewardship of a still beautiful land gives our children a place to call home.

So for Iran, will they win? The experts that Tom cites will weigh in. But I know who lost. That is us.

Bes's avatar

Sterling work, as usual.

minuteman's avatar

I follow myself every and each one of the commentariat you mentioned. Maybe you would also like Scott Ritter and Alon Mizrahi.

Thomas Neuburger's avatar

Thanks, minuteman. I read Mizrahi on Twitter — he’s on my Middle East List (https://x.com/i/lists/1933680563291918584) — and is frequently good.

Ritter I listen to on podcasts, but I find he often “shoots from the hip,” so I don’t find the value I see in others. Still, he’s not to be ignoredl