5 Comments
User's avatar
Blackthorn's avatar

Great, and rightly the topic of the day. Couple of complementary points: sole authority to green-light the use of nuclear weapons does not quite equate to sufficient or unitary authority to do so. Presidential authorization may de facto be a necessary but insufficient condition, i.e. the military could slow or halt the train in various ways. I'd be surprised if the military doesn't have safeguards in place against a deranged or self-defeating launch order. They should: it's a matter of national security. They'll never say so, though, because the mindset of Cold War nuclear deterrence holds it necessary that the other side believe that presidential authority is sufficient. If they conclude it's more complicated than that, and that a decision to retaliate could be slow enough for a second strike to derail, they'd be more inclined to think they could get away with a first strike. So went the reasoning.

In short, the US Govt has every reason to put out the word that presidential authority is both necessary and sufficient to use nukes, and simultaneously to arrange that this not be so in reality—that such an order would have to clear several hurdles of safeguards.

So we don't know what happens when the President pushes the button. Or maybe we just learned, thanks to Larry Johnson.

As to whether this constitutes the Pentagon taking control, well...the military is obliged to follow lawful orders. In lieu of a Congressional declaration of war or an imminent mortal threat, no president can lawfully order use of deadly military force, with any weapons, let alone nukes. The consequences of a US nuclear attack would be so irreparable that the Pentagon is, it seems to me, justified in establishing special safeguards, and in applying this true definition of lawful order. I have no great faith in the Pentagon's judgement or honesty, but this would seem to be a case of the Constitution, not the Pentagon, taking control.

Thomas Neuburger's avatar

> the US Govt has every reason to put out the word that presidential authority is both necessary and sufficient to use nukes, and simultaneously to arrange that this not be so in reality—that such an order would have to clear several hurdles of safeguards

Would love to think you're right!

FINTEL's avatar

Larry Johnson as a source is like using Sidney Powell as a source. It's entertaining but no one in their right mind would choose Johnson to leak to.

Mark Oglesby's avatar

As to "The President, however, does not need the concurrence of either his military leaders or the U.S. Congress to order the launch of nuclear weapons. Neither the military nor Congress can overrule these orders." The military can say no! How? Coup Trump then and there! The military is mandated by international law to NOT follow such orders as this is genocide on a world stage. I sincerely believe the military will arrest Trump and overthrow his insanity. And that's the lynch-pen, the Commander-in-Chief's insane! Therefore, they need not obey His Trumpishness. In the end, Trump will die in his bed, his dismiss, his own damn fault!

the suck of sorrow's avatar

Is this war legal?

There is no formal declaration of war by Congress. Nor did Congress issue an authorization for use of military force.

I can see top echelons of the military not cooperating in committing a horrendous war crime.

It comes down to whether Don and Pete can find a bomber or missile squadron that will accept an order independently of the wishes of higher command. Is that even technically possible?

And whose God does the persuading? Pope Leo's or Paula White-Cain's?